Why We Can't Stop Watching Love Island - A Rollercoaster of Dopamine, Drama, and Real Life Reflection

There hasn’t been a single week in the past three months where Love Island hasn’t come up in a therapy session. Sometimes it’s shared with a sense of empowerment, other times with a guilty laugh and a “I know I shouldn’t be watching this…” vibe. More than a few clients have admitted it’s their go-to weekend ritual — a full-blown, sun-soaked escape in bingeable form.

As a therapist with a deep curiosity about pop culture’s influence on the psyche, I decided to watch it myself. And well… that gave birth to this blog.

Thanks for reading! You may also subscribe for free to my Substack at TriggeredandConscious.Substack.com to receive new posts and support my work.

Let’s be honest — Love Island isn’t just a show. It’s a neon-lit safari of human behavior, packed with cheeky flirtations, unhinged declarations of love, and enough fake eyelashes to cause a blackout in Sephora.

If you’ve ever found yourself bingeing in a trance while stress-texting your best friend, welcome. You’re not alone- there is nothing “wrong with you” at all !

You’re human.
And maybe a little fabulous.

Lessons from a Casa Mojo Dojo villa (a nod to the Barbie movie's satirical take on male-dominated spaces), where the Barbies keep letting the Kens in—and what we can learn from this dopamine-fueled roller coaster of a show.

If you’ve ever told yourself, “I’ll just watch one more episode,” only to realize it’s 2 a.m. and you’re still glued to the screen—this post is for you.

There’s no shame here. Love Island is entertaining, addictive, and emotionally charged in ways that pull us in for reasons that are anything but shallow. In fact, watching this show can open the door to meaningful insight about our own attachment styles, emotional triggers, and the rollercoaster of human connection.

Let’s break it down together—psychologically, in a non-judgmental and mindful way, intended for a bit of information, entertainment, and opportunities for personal growth!

Why Love Island Hooks Us (and Won’t Let Go)

- Dopamine (and other dangerously seductive neurotransmitters)

It’s not just the spray tans and steamy fire pit make-outs — it’s the intermittent reinforcement. Love Island delivers a steady drip of surprise texts, dramatic exits, makeup kisses, and unexpected twists — all of which mimic the emotional highs and lows that keep our nervous systems on edge, and glued to the screen. Psychologists call this “variable reward.” Some call it addiction.

Someone couples up? POW! Your brain lights up like it just hit the jackpot on a Vegas slot machine.
Make-outs under the fairy lights? Cue the oxytocin — the infamous cuddle hormone.
A sudden betrayal or screaming match? Cortisol spike! Fight-or-flight activated.

And then… the emotional crash. The suspense hangover. The need to hit “next episode” just to feel OK again.

It’s a perfectly engineered cocktail of dopamine, drama, and disaster recovery. And anyone with a nervous system is down to order another round!

- Attachment Activation

It’s relatable… but just distant enough.
Watching emotionally intense interactions — the love triangles, betrayals, and in the fluorescent lights on the couch meltdowns — lights up the same attachment circuits in our own real-life relationships.

Your social radar flips on.
Your stomach drops.
You think: “Ugh, I’ve been here before.”

But this time, it’s not your heartbreak.
You’re safe on the couch, rooting for your favorite or yelling at the screen as someone makes a decision that might seriously ruin their summer (and their dignity).

It’s emotional déjà vu with a buffer — which is exactly why it hits so hard… and feels so good.

-Identification, Projection & Our Tribal Brain on Reality TV

It’s not just entertainment—your primal brain, is working overtime.

Love Island taps into the very systems that helped our ancestors survive: Our need to belong, to bond, and to stay alert to potential threats.

In other words, your limbic system (aka your emotional brain) is doing what it was designed to do—scanning for connection, betrayal, and survival cues… but in bikinis and tons of “eye-candy” for the masses.

We don’t just watch the show—we feel it.
We attach.
We project.
We pick favorites, form social bonds, and get genuinely upset when someone betrays the group or makes the “wrong” choice. Why? Because our brains aren’t great at distinguishing real-life social dynamics from the ones on-screen.

AND THEN THE MUSIC HITS just right…

Music directly activates the same emotional memory circuits, that limbic emotional part of the nervous system, that deepen your attachment to the characters—whether your cheering yes for them or yelling no at them….

Slow-mo R & B dreamy walk-ins. Upbeat EDM drops. Melancholic piano overlays after a brutal heartbreak. The soundtrack is basically emotional glitter - bombed straight into your nervous system.

This is why the show hooks us—and why it sometimes leaves us with a weird emotional hangover. We’re not just observers. We’re emotionally invested.

-Hope + Chaos

Even when a relationship on Love Island seems toxic, unhealthy, or is clearly making someone miserable—we still hold out hope they’ll figure it out. That dynamic mirrors real life for many viewers who’ve stayed in difficult relationships longer than they wanted to.

Watching someone else’s emotional chaos can be a strange kind of relief:
No decisions to make.
No texts to agonize over.
No boundaries to wrestle with.

Just popcorn, a mocktail cocktail, and someone else’s love life melting down in real time.

And then something hits you:
You see yourself in it.
That moment of recognition? That’s not a problem—it’s a portal.

It’s where the healing can begin.

The Darker Side of the Villa : Misogyny, Fantasy & Filtered Chaos

While Love Island serves as entertainment, it also mirrors some of the more troubling dynamics that exist in real life—particularly around gender roles, self-worth, and emotional (un)availability.

• Misogyny and Objectification: Female contestants are often judged harshly—by Islanders and viewers—for behaviors that are praised in the men. The focus skews toward who’s the “hottest,” not who’s the most emotionally attuned or self-aware. This over-sexualization reduces women to their bodies and reinforces the idea that sexual chemistry matters more than genuine connection or compatibility.

• Female Self-Worth Tied to Male Approval: Women are praised when chosen, pitied when dumped, and often portrayed as valuable only when they’re wanted. Cue the pit-in-your-stomach trigger for anyone who’s ever felt unseen or replaced for “not being good enough.”

• Unrealistic Ideals for Men, Too: While women are more frequently judged, men aren’t immune. The show glorifies sculpted abs, chiseled jawlines, and hyper-masculine energy—fueling toxic ideals where stoicism and dominance equal desirability. This kind of perfectionism serves no one, leaving little room for authenticity on either side.

• Hot Girl Summer with a Side of Public Humiliation: Some scenes feel like a digital colosseum, where vulnerable emotions are served up on a platter for public consumption.

• Unrealistic Beauty Standards for All: Surgically enhanced faces, snatched abs, and flawless tans create a filtered fantasy that fuels body comparison and shame across the board.

• Performative Vulnerability: Emotional “breakthroughs” are often timed with dramatic camera cuts and moody music (hi again, limbic system)—more curated than connected. It’s not exactly a masterclass in healthy intimacy.

These aren’t just Love Island problems. They’re reflections of the cultural soup we all swim in. But noticing them—without shame—is a powerful step toward unhooking from toxic narratives.

While Love Island serves as entertainment, it also mirrors some of the more troubling dynamics that exist in real life—particularly around gender roles, self-worth, and healthy vs. unhealthy relationships.

Journal Prompts for Conscious Binge-Watching And What the Casa Mojo Dojo Villa Can Teach Us About Love and Life

Watching Love Island doesn’t make you shallow—it makes you human. If parts of the show stir discomfort, longing, or confusion, that might be an invitation to explore what you truly want more (or less) of in your own relationships.

Rather than shame ourselves for watching, we can ask:

-What parts of this show/What about this show activates something deeper in me beneath the glitter and chaos?

-Do I long for the fantasy but avoid the risk of real connection? Do I feel seen or erased by the dynamics in the show ?

-What are you drawn to—and what are you ready to outgrow?

- Who do I relate to most on this season of Love Island—and why?

- What relationship dynamic makes me feel activated- frustrated, obsessed, sad, hopeful

- Is there a moment on the show that reminded me of one of my own past relationships?

- Do I root for chaos or connection—and what might that say about my own emotional patterns?

- What would I do differently if I were in that villa? What boundary would I set?

- Have I ever accepted breadcrumbs of affection while calling it love? What do I want to do differently in this regard in my (dating) relationships ?

- What does ‘emotional safety’ actually feel like—and how often do I see that modeled on the show?

This isn’t a takedown of Love Island. It’s a mirror—and mirrors can be powerful tools for healing.

If Love Island hits a little too close to home—stirring up old wounds, longings, or relationship patterns—you’re in good company!

Curiosity is where healing begins. So keep watching… but maybe start writing, too.

You’re not just watching “trash TV.” You’re decoding love, lust, and life—with a side of booty shorts and intoxicating beat drops.

And if it’s stirring up more than entertainment? That’s not weakness. That’s self-awareness knocking on your door, and I’ve got room on the virtual Zoom couch.

Let’s talk.

Thanks for reading!

© 2025 Cecily Longo, LMFT

Disclaimer: Please note this article is not a substitute for professional therapy or mental health treatment, and reflects the opinions, experiences, and personal reflections of this author. This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. If you are in need of support, please reach out to a licensed provider in your area- or if you think we could be a good fit to work together, feel free to contact me if you are located in California, and looking for someone who gets it. If you believe you are experiencing a mental health emergency, please call 911 or the 988 crisis hotline, or local crisis support services in your area.